Change Orders in Construction: Complete Guide for Contractors

Construction projects rarely proceed exactly as planned. Whether it’s design modifications, material substitutions, or unforeseen site conditions, change orders have become an integral part of the construction industry. For contractors, understanding how to properly manage change orders can mean the difference between project success and financial disaster.

Change orders affect over 75% of construction projects, with the average project experiencing cost increases of 10-15% due to changes. Despite their prevalence, many contractors struggle with change order management, leading to disputes, delayed payments, and strained client relationships.

What Are Change Orders in Construction?

A construction change order is a written document that modifies the original construction contract. It formally authorizes changes to the project scope, timeline, or cost. Change orders serve as legal amendments to the original agreement, protecting both contractors and clients by clearly documenting approved modifications.

Change orders typically include:

• Description of the work to be added, deleted, or modified
• Impact on project cost (increase or decrease)
• Schedule implications
• Signatures from all authorized parties
• Reference to the original contract

Types of Change Orders

Understanding different types of change orders helps contractors prepare appropriate responses:

Owner-Requested Changes: Modifications initiated by the client, such as design upgrades, additional features, or material substitutions.

Design-Related Changes: Adjustments required due to design errors, omissions, or conflicts discovered during construction.

Field Condition Changes: Modifications necessary due to unforeseen site conditions, such as soil issues, utility conflicts, or environmental concerns.

Regulatory Changes: Adjustments required to comply with updated building codes, permit requirements, or safety regulations.

Common Causes of Change Orders

Research by McKinsey & Company identifies several primary drivers of change orders in construction projects:

Design Issues

Incomplete or inaccurate design documents account for approximately 40% of all change orders. Common design-related issues include:

• Missing details or specifications
• Conflicts between architectural and engineering drawings
• Inadequate site surveys
• Failure to coordinate between design disciplines

Owner-Requested Modifications

Client-initiated changes represent about 25% of change orders. These often result from:

• Evolving project requirements
• Budget reallocations
• Market condition changes
• User feedback during construction

Unforeseen Site Conditions

Unexpected site conditions contribute to roughly 20% of change orders, including:

• Subsurface conditions different from soil reports
• Hidden utilities or structures
• Environmental issues
• Weather-related delays requiring scope adjustments

The Change Order Process

A systematic approach to change order management protects contractors and ensures proper documentation. The process typically follows these steps:

1. Identification and Documentation

When a potential change is identified:

• Document the issue immediately with photos, measurements, and written descriptions
• Notify all relevant parties promptly
• Stop work in affected areas if necessary
• Gather supporting documentation (drawings, specifications, reports)

2. Impact Assessment

Evaluate the change’s effects on:

• Cost: Calculate direct costs (materials, labor, equipment) and indirect costs (overhead, supervision)
• Schedule: Determine timeline impacts and potential delays to other work
• Quality: Assess impacts on project performance and standards
• Safety: Identify any new safety considerations or requirements

3. Pricing and Proposal

Develop a comprehensive change order proposal that includes:

• Detailed scope of work description
• Itemized cost breakdown
• Schedule impact analysis
• Supporting calculations and documentation
• Clear terms and conditions

4. Negotiation and Approval

Work with the client and design team to:

• Present the proposal clearly and professionally
• Justify costs with detailed explanations
• Negotiate fair terms for all parties
• Obtain written approval before proceeding

Best Practices for Change Order Management

Implementing proven strategies can significantly improve change order outcomes for contractors:

Establish Clear Procedures

Develop standardized processes for:

• Change identification and notification procedures
• Documentation requirements and formats
• Approval hierarchies and timeframes
• Communication protocols

According to Construction Executive magazine, contractors with formal change order procedures experience 30% fewer disputes and faster resolution times.

Maintain Detailed Records

Comprehensive documentation is crucial for successful change order management:

• Keep daily logs of work performed and conditions encountered
• Photograph all relevant conditions before, during, and after work
• Maintain correspondence files with all project stakeholders
• Document all verbal communications with written follow-ups

Price Changes Fairly and Accurately

Accurate pricing builds trust and reduces disputes:

• Use detailed cost accounting to support pricing
• Include appropriate markups for overhead and profit
• Consider both direct and indirect cost impacts
• Provide transparent cost breakdowns

Communicate Proactively

Effective communication prevents small issues from becoming major problems:

• Notify stakeholders of potential changes immediately
• Provide regular updates on change order status
• Use clear, professional language in all communications
• Confirm verbal agreements in writing

Legal Considerations and Contract Language

Understanding the legal aspects of change orders protects contractors from disputes and ensures enforceability:

Essential Contract Clauses

Include specific change order provisions in construction contracts:

• Change Order Procedures: Detailed process for requesting, reviewing, and approving changes
• Pricing Methods: Specify how changes will be priced (unit prices, cost-plus, time and materials)
• Timeline Requirements: Establish deadlines for change order requests and approvals
• Notice Requirements: Define when and how parties must notify each other of changes

Dispute Prevention

Research by Navigant Consulting shows that clear contract language reduces change order disputes by up to 50%. Key strategies include:

• Define scope boundaries clearly in the original contract
• Specify what constitutes a change versus included work
• Establish dispute resolution procedures
• Include provisions for documenting changed conditions

Technology Tools for Change Order Management

Modern construction management software can streamline change order processes and improve accuracy:

Project Management Software

Comprehensive platforms offer:

• Automated change order workflows
• Digital approval processes
• Cost tracking and reporting
• Document management and storage

Mobile Applications

Field-based tools enable:

• Real-time documentation with photos and notes
• GPS-tagged condition reports
• Instant communication with office staff
• Digital signature capture

Cost Estimation Tools

Specialized software provides:

• Accurate cost calculations for change work
• Database of current material and labor costs
• Productivity factors for different work types
• Professional proposal formatting

Managing Change Order Disputes

Despite best efforts, disputes may arise. Effective dispute management minimizes impacts on projects and relationships:

Early Intervention

Address potential disputes quickly:

• Identify disagreements early in the process
• Schedule face-to-face meetings to discuss issues
• Focus on project success rather than fault assignment
• Seek win-win solutions that benefit all parties

Documentation as Support

Strong documentation supports dispute resolution:

• Present clear evidence of changed conditions
• Provide detailed cost justifications
• Reference contract terms and industry standards
• Demonstrate good faith efforts to minimize impacts

Professional Assistance

Consider involving neutral third parties:

• Mediation for collaborative problem-solving
• Expert witnesses for technical issues
• Legal counsel for complex disputes
• Industry consultants for specialized knowledge

Financial Impact Management

Change orders can significantly impact project profitability. Contractors must manage financial aspects carefully:

Cash Flow Considerations

Change orders affect cash flow through:

• Upfront costs for additional materials and labor
• Delayed billing until change order approval
• Extended payment cycles for disputed changes
• Impact on progress payment schedules

Profit Protection

Maintain profitability by:

• Including appropriate markups on change work
• Accounting for increased supervision and coordination costs
• Considering efficiency impacts on base contract work
• Negotiating fair payment terms for change orders

Change Order Prevention Strategies

While change orders are often unavoidable, contractors can minimize their frequency and impact:

Thorough Pre-Construction Planning

• Conduct comprehensive design reviews before construction
• Identify potential issues during preconstruction meetings
• Verify site conditions through detailed surveys
• Coordinate with all design disciplines

Clear Scope Definition

• Define project boundaries precisely in contracts
• Specify quality standards and performance criteria
• Clarify responsibility for unforeseen conditions
• Include detailed specifications and drawings

Proactive Communication

• Establish regular communication schedules
• Encourage early identification of potential issues
• Maintain open dialogue with all stakeholders
• Document all project decisions and changes

Measuring Change Order Management Success

Track key performance indicators to evaluate change order management effectiveness:

Quantitative Metrics

• Change Order Frequency: Number of change orders per project
• Cost Impact: Percentage of original contract value
• Approval Time: Average days from submission to approval
• Dispute Rate: Percentage of change orders that result in disputes

Qualitative Measures

• Client satisfaction with change order handling
• Team efficiency in processing changes
• Quality of change order documentation
• Relationship impact with project stakeholders

“Successful contractors view change orders not as problems to avoid, but as opportunities to demonstrate professionalism and add value to their clients’ projects.” – Engineering News-Record

Mastering change order management requires dedication to process improvement, clear communication, and professional documentation. Contractors who invest in developing these capabilities position themselves for long-term success in an industry where change is the only constant.

Ready to transform your change order management process? Schedule a personalized demo.

---

Sources

• Construction Dive – Change Orders Statistics – Statistics on change order frequency affecting over 75% of construction projects
• McKinsey & Company – Construction Productivity – Research identifying primary drivers of change orders in construction
• Construction Executive – Change Order Best Practices – Study showing 30% reduction in disputes with formal procedures
• Navigant Consulting – Construction Claims Study – Research on contract language reducing change order disputes by 50%
• Engineering News-Record – Change Order Best Practices – Quote about successful contractors viewing change orders as opportunities